| Year | 1st Place | 2nd Place | 3rd Place |
| 2021 | Blake Kotach 64.3 pound Bluefin Tuna | Danny Martinez 59.7 pound Bluefin Tuna | Dave Ploesell 30.4 pound Bluefin Tuna |
| 2020 | Dave Rechel 34.6 pound yellowtail | Lance Joseph 15.4 pound yellowtail | Evan Wagley 13.8 pound yellowtail |
| 2019 | Mike Strazzula 20.8 pound yellowtail | Gabe Cooley 19.00 pound yellowtail | Patrick Friend 11.2 pound dorado |
| 2018 | Aaron Hill 24.8 pound dorado | Lance Joseph 22.4 pound yellowtail | Mike Feldman 22.0 pound yellowtail |
| 2017 | Gene Emory 27.1 pound yellowtail | Craig White 26.3 pound yellowtail | Zack Wilcox 24.0 pound yellowtail |
| 2016 | Mike Feldman 21.4 pound yellowtail | Jason Johnson 13.8 pound yellowtail | Mike Shrin 12.2 pound Dorado |
| 2015 | Austin Borden | Myrran Mckeen | Al Hansen |
| 2014 | Al Hansen | —– | —– |
| 2013 | Christopher Davis 44.4 pound white seabass | Al Hansen 43.1 pound white seabass | John Carpenter 36.2 pound white seabass |
| 2012 | Chrisopher Davis 40.4 pound white seabass | Justin Schlaefli White seabass | Joshua Liberty White seabass |
| 2011 | Justin Schaefli 38.7 pound white seabass | —– | —– |
| 2010 | Joshua Liberty 43.5 pound white seabass | —– | —– |
| 2009 | Brian Webster 29.6 pound yellowtail | Mark Morgan 21.1 pound yellowtail | Simeon McDonald 20.8 pound yellowtail |
| 2008 | Ed Harris 47.3 pound white seabass | Maurizio Mangini 37.4 pound white seabass | John Hanson 24.2 pound white seabass |
| 2007 | Bill Bender 28.2 pound yellowtail | Gil Gacula 23.2 pound yellowtail | Tom Harding 23.2 pound dorado |
| 2006 | Tom Keough 16.7 pound yellowtail | Eric Friedrichsen 16.5 pound dorado | David Brooks 15.8 pound dorado |
| 2005 | Tim Kohl 56 pound white seabass | Phil Wells 45.4 pound white seabass | Tim Stafford 40 pound white seabass |
| 2004 | Mark Morgan 52.2 pound white seabass | Maurizio Mangini | Phil Wells 19.5 pound yellowtail |
| 2003 | Colin Smith 53.4 pound white seabass | Phil Wells 22.8 pound white seabass | Jim Anderson 20 pound white seabass |
| 2002 | Colin Smith 44 pound white seabass | Grant Milbrand 18.7 pound yellowtail | Bill Bender 18.1 pound yellowtail |
| 2001 | Tom Keough 27.8 pound yellowtail | Leon Navarro 18.9 pound yellowtail | Dick Glen 17.4 pound yellowtail |
| 2000 | Bill Wagner 27.8 pound yellowtail | Maurizio Mangini 18.8 pound yellowtail | Rick Breitenbach 17.5 pound white seabass |
| 1999 | Rich Breitenback 34.3 pound white seabass | Steve Salas 30.6 pound white seabass | Paul Romanolski 17.5 pound yellowtail |
| 1998 | Chis Brown 15.7 pound yellowtail | Duane Smith 15.3 pound yellowtail | Pepo Biscarini 13.8 pound yellowtail |
| 1997 | Russ Gibfried 18 pound yellowtail | Steve Geyer 14 pound dorado | Randy Long 11 pound yellowtail |
| 1996 | Alex Arrues 31.5 pound Yellowtail | Maurizio Mangini Yellowtail | Pepo Biscarini Yellowtail |
| 1995 | Randy Long 19 pound yellowtail | —– | —– |